POS Systems Comparison

Last updated: 2026-05-20

POS Total Cost Calculator (3-Year TCO)

Headline monthly cost is a fraction of real POS spend. Enter your volume below — we show the true 3-year total across 5 major systems using verified April 2026 rates.

Bottom line up front:

For a $30K/month-volume small restaurant over 3 years, Square Premium typically totals $11,900–$13,400, Toast $14,200–$16,500, Clover via reseller $17,000–$22,000+. Your actual numbers depend on which plan you pick — use the calculator below.

Your inputs

Approx. card-payment revenue per month per location.

Reseller markup is often $100-200/mo — confirm at signup.

3-year total cost (ranked cheapest first)

POS Best plan Software 36mo Processing 36mo Hardware Hidden fees Total 36mo

Estimates only. Processing rates use published April 2026 rates (your actual rate may vary with plan tier + negotiation). Hardware estimates assume 1 terminal + peripherals per location. Hidden fees estimated at industry midpoints.

How we calculate TCO

Answer capsule: total cost of ownership = software subscription × 36 months + processing fees (rate × volume × 36 × locations) + one-time hardware outlay + estimated hidden fees. Hidden fees model reseller markups where relevant. Labor, integrations, and early-termination costs are excluded.

Per-vendor assumptions
  • Square: $0 Free plan for QSR/small retail, $49 Plus for growing businesses, $149 Premium for high volume. In-person rate 2.6%+15¢ (free) to 2.4%+15¢ (Premium). No contract, no hidden fees.
  • Toast: $69 POS plan + $50/mo online ordering. In-person 2.49%+15¢ paid. 1-3 year contract. Hardware $599-$1,500 per location.
  • Clover direct: $14.95-$354/mo per device. Restaurant 2.3%+10¢, retail 2.6%+10¢. No hidden fees buying direct.
  • Clover reseller: same rate card + $100-200/mo statement/PCI/platform fees (typical). 36-month contracts common.
  • Shopify POS: Free with Shopify Basic ($39/mo), POS Pro $89/mo per location. In-person 2.5%+30¢ (Basic) to 2.4%+30¢ (Plus $105/mo).
  • Lightspeed Retail: $109-$339/mo per location. In-person 2.6%+10¢. Retail + specialty focus. Deeper inventory.

Frequently asked

Answer capsule: real POS cost is dominated by processing fees at any non-trivial volume — a 0.2% rate difference compounds to thousands over 3 years. Software subscription differences are usually smaller. Hidden fees (statement, PCI, platform) can erase the "cheapest rate" advantage if you buy through a reseller.

Why does POS TCO matter more than monthly price?

Headline monthly cost is usually under 20% of true 3-year spend. Processing fees on transaction volume dominate. A $30K/month restaurant pays $10,800/yr at 2.6%+15¢ in processing alone — the $69/mo Toast subscription is a rounding error next to that.

How accurate are these numbers?

Base pricing verified April 2026. Processing rates use standard published rates — your negotiated rate may be better at higher volume. Hidden fees use industry midpoints; reseller contracts vary widely. Use this as a starting point, not a final quote.

Why is Clover flagged as potentially higher?

The direct-from-Clover rate is genuinely competitive. But most Clover terminals are sold through banks and independent sales organizations that add $100-200/mo in statement, PCI, and platform fees not shown upfront. Set "buying channel" to direct if you're going to Clover.com.

What if I want to negotiate processing rates?

Above roughly $30K/mo card volume, Toast and Clover direct will typically negotiate. Square and Shopify are closer to non-negotiable. Bring quotes from competitors — "Toast quoted me 2.35%" is leverage with Clover.

Does this account for hardware over 3 years?

Included as one-time upfront cost per location. Hardware lifespan assumes 3-5 years so no replacement mid-period. Some vendors (Clover reseller) push hardware leases that cost 3× outright purchase — always buy, never lease.

Still comparing?

Use our head-to-head comparisons for deeper analysis:

Or get 3 matched POS quotes sent to your inbox — free.

Get the monthly roundup

One email per month. New comparisons, price changes, and the rare deal worth knowing about. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.